FatwaIslam.Com : Praying behind one that is not proficient in reciting the qur'aan

Islamic Fatwa s

1346 Fatwas Available

Important categories:

Purification

Prayer

Fasting

Charity

Pilgrimage

Tuesday 10 September 2024

Search FatwaIslam:

• Advanced Search
• Preferences

Home » Worship and Jurisprudence » Prayer » Prayer in Congregation

Praying behind one that is not proficient in reciting the qur'aan

Question:

Is it correct (to say) that if the salaat is lead by one who is not proficient in reciting the qur'aan, in the presence of one who has memorised more than him, that their prayer (i.e. the congregation who are behind him) is not valid?

Answer:

It is a must that we know the meaning of our statement 'not being proficient in reciting the qur'aan'.

If the intent is that he not a 'fine' reciter then the salaat is sound.

As for if the meaning of him not being proficient, is that he makes the type of mistakes that change the meaning and perverts the words, then yes the prayer is not sound behind him with the presence of one who is more proficient in his recitation.

Shaykh Muhammad bin Saalih al-`Uthaymeen

Kitaabud da'wah (5) 2/108

Translated by Abu Hakeem Bilal Davis

Other subjects of interest:

Prescribed Punishments